The Winvest Journal | Miami 2026
How We Screen Tenants in Miami
In 2026 we reviewed 98% of applications the same day, approved about 1 in 2 applicants, and had a 0% eviction rate among tenants we placed. Before any owner hands over keys, we want to know whether the applicant can pay and what their background and eviction history show. We also want to hear how they treated their last landlord, because that says a lot about whether they'll look after a place that isn't theirs.

- 98%Applications reviewed the same day92 of 94
- 0%Eviction rate among tenants we placed
- 12%Eviction rate among tenants a previous manager placed on units we took over
- 96%Tenant renewal rate
- About 1 in 2Applicants approvedAbout 2.1 applications per approval
- 18 daysAverage list to lease time
Winvest internal data, 2026.
Income
Can they pay?
Money comes first, so we start by verifying income and pulling credit. A tenant who earns enough on paper but carries a pile of late accounts makes us look twice. So does one with thin credit and a steady job for six years. Neither one decides it alone, so we look at the whole file before we say anything to the owner.
The owner sets the income and credit bar with us before the listing goes live. There's no single minimum score across everything we manage. Two condos in the same Brickell tower can have different standards, because each owner decides what matters to them. Once it's set, every adult applying for that unit is held to it.
Background
Background and eviction history

We run criminal background and eviction history on every adult applicant through CRS. We weigh a criminal record as appropriate. Eviction filings matter most. They tell us more about how a tenancy might end than anything else on the report.
Rental history and landlord references fill in the rest. A past landlord who says the rent came late every month, or the unit came back trashed, matters more to us than a good credit score.
We also confirm every applicant is who they say they are.
In all my years of managing rentals, I have never had a squatter. But I've seen it happen. A property manager got lazy on the screening and rushed a tenant in. The owner spent over a year in a legal battle and more than $10,000 to get that tenant out. Half the game is avoiding a terrible tenant like that.
The property
Will they respect the property?
Rental history is the best signal we have. The applicants we feel best about paid on time and left their last place in good shape, and their old landlord would rent to them again. When the history says the opposite, we say so plainly in our recommendation.
The decision
Who makes the final call?
The owner makes the final call, and owners handle it one of two ways. Some approve every applicant themselves, and they get the CRS results with our recommendation against their criteria. Others let us approve anyone who meets those criteria. When a screening report leads to a denial, the applicant gets the adverse action notice the federal Fair Credit Reporting Act requires.
We move fast on our end, too. In 2026 we reviewed 98% of applications the same day they came in.
Every applicant is held to the same criteria under fair housing law.
In 2026 the eviction rate was 0% for tenants we placed and 12% for tenants a previous manager had placed on units we took over. That gap is the first thing to look at when you're deciding whether a property manager is worth it in Miami.
Not legal advice. Talk to a Florida attorney about your own property.
Owner questions
FAQ
What does Winvest check when screening a tenant?
We check income, credit, criminal background, eviction history and rental history, and we check landlord references when there are any.
Does Winvest use a minimum credit score?
Not one for every property. Each owner sets the income and credit bar for their unit with us before it's listed, and every applicant for that unit is held to the same bar.
Who approves the tenant, the owner or Winvest?
You do, unless you'd rather leave it to us. Some owners approve each applicant after reading our recommendation, and others let us approve anyone who meets their criteria.
